Skip to content
QuickAlphaTrackBase

The Educational Messaging Spotlighted by an Academy Award-Winning Film – Is It Actually Effective?

When her young daughter was told to memorize a verse celebrating Russia's "powerful army" for a class activity, Nina from Moscow thought it was too much.

She has faced difficulties to insulate her child from a ever-increasing number of so-called "nationalistic" lessons in the classroom.

This escalation of war-focused propaganda aimed at Russian students has been vividly portrayed for a worldwide audience in an award-winning documentary.

The film, featuring footage from a ex- school events coordinator from a provincial town in the Urals, shows how educational activities were increasingly integrated with pro-government narratives after the full-scale military action of Ukraine.

What worries the mother most is that her daughter genuinely enjoys taking part in the state-backed initiative.

"She adores her teacher, she gets along with her classmates – she enjoys feeling like a part of it," she says.

The mother worries that openly objecting to school activities could socially isolate her daughter. Once, when she decided to keep her child home to skip a patriotic event, her daughter was disappointed. "My concern is her to feel like she doesn't belong," she adds.

The Film's Insights

The documentary shows how the filmmaker was reluctantly swept up in the government propaganda machine.

Additional rituals and mandatory lessons were rolled out, aimed at teaching the government's perspective on history and current events.

History books were updated to include the ongoing conflict, termed as a "special operation."

These measures have persisted. Just last month, the government announced plans for a official list of play materials for nurseries to foster "patriotism."

The core messages are clear: the military campaign is necessary, and patriotism requires full support. At home, however, some children hear different views.

Young Students' Experiences

One young boy, a student, enthusiastically recites what he has learnt in his "values" lessons: topics ranging from great Russian poets to friendship and even military technology.

"We were taught this is how to get ready for war," he says.

His mother, Marina, refrains from publicly discussing her views in front of him, fearing he might share it in public.

"A vocal anti-war position might draw unnecessary attention," the mother says.

Psychological Analysis

Navigating the gap between school messages and family beliefs is challenging, according to a child psychologist.

"A child must live in this environment – attending school, being part of the class," the expert notes. "However, this isn't parents should align with the propaganda. But there is no need in adopting a political stance in front of your child."

She advises parents focus on universal values like the sanctity of human life and dialogue – rather than directly confronting the official line.

Studies indicate children in early grades are particularly susceptible to messages from teachers and leaders. "When told to a small child that war is good, they will accept it," the psychotherapist adds.

"If parents actively disagree with state messaging, family influence usually prevails in the end," says a researcher in behavioural genetics.

However, when the state dominates nearly all media and education and different viewpoints are limited, the long-term effect is less predictable. This is the case in the present Russian environment.

Historical studies into 20th-century indoctrination have found that school-based messaging can have enduring effects, especially when reinforced by the wider social environment.

Uneven Application

The application of government directives varies widely across schools.

Some institutions follow them enthusiastically, while others dilute or quietly resist the requirements. Individual teachers may adapt, minimize, or ignore the official content.

In scenes from the documentary, children are seen handed Russian flags during a school assembly to watch a speech about a state-run youth organization.

In another instance, a class is told that the "enemy" will try to influence from within their communities.

Teenage Disengagement

The compulsory talks, known as "Important Conversations," are frequently met with indifference by teenagers.

One teenager from St Petersburg, a student, says they are "tedious."

"Hardly anyone participates in the discussion. We just are present and listen, then leave," she describes.

"Compelling citizens to perform rituals of patriotism is a way of reminding them of the state's overwhelming power," notes a professor in Russian studies. This perception is reinforced by state-run media and managed public discourse, he adds.

To further capitalize on this "environment," authorities made easier the pathway for school-leavers to enlist in the military in 2023, at times offering financial incentives as motivation.

Maia, who holds her parents' critical view of the war, does not discuss at school and is unsure what her peers truly think.

"Initially I was anxious that I would clash with those who backed the war," she remembers. "But nowadays, everyone behaves so cautiously that the atmosphere feels normal."

By

Melissa Salazar

Elena Voss is a quantitative analyst with over a decade of experience in algorithmic trading and portfolio management.

QuickAlphaTrackBase

Type to search articles.