Residents like Rangsan Angda and his community in frontier regions of Thailand had long since prepared to leave, worried that a halt in hostilities with neighboring Cambodia would soon collapse.
The peace agreement – negotiated with the help of a third-party statesman who declared himself “a peacemaker” after playing a role in concluding five days of violent conflict in July – had seemed unstable from the outset. “Both sides are confronting one another all the time,” remarked Angda, 50.
On Sunday, the warning he dreaded rang out on loudspeakers across his village, announcing that fighting had again erupted. For the second time this year, everyone was ordered to evacuate immediately. Families piled into their cars or sought transportation with local officials. For hours they lined up on jammed streets, making their way to religious sites, learning centers, and administrative compounds.
Over half a million individuals across Cambodia and Thailand have been forced to travel in the same way since the skirmishes broke out on Sunday. No one knows the date of their eventual return, or how the most recent bout of violence might be stopped.
The statesman, who oversaw the signing of an strengthened truce agreement in October, told reporters this week he would speak with the prime ministers of Thailand and Cambodia, saying he could stop the clashes “rather fast”.
“I believe I can persuade them to cease hostilities. No one else has this ability,” the mediator said.
In the disputed zones of Thailand, many doubt his optimism. “If he did have power to sort the conflict there wouldn’t be this war right now,” said Patcharee Kotmakti, 45. She left her home on Monday, when the sound of shooting first rang out across her village.
Just four months ago, clashes were so intense that her house trembled from the force. “One could say I have become accustomed to it,” she said.
She worries the fighting could continue for many weeks. “It will be impossible to cover my expenses,” she said. Kotmakti and many of her neighbours have no fixed income and instead depend on daily work. “Individuals living in these zones don’t have money, they have to borrow money and pay it back with interest.”
She just wanted the situation to end, she said. “The sooner the better.”
The statesman has previously used the leverage of trade penalties to pressure Thailand and Cambodia to stop fighting. A research fellow said this intervention was “absolutely pivotal” in bringing an end to the earlier fighting. “Previously, Bangkok refused any external negotiation,” he added.
Whether the same effect can be achieved today is uncertain. With an election due in 2026, the Thai prime minister might choose to appeal to nationalist sentiment by maintaining that Thailand had operated within its rights in protection of its land. Doing so “might find support among large segments of Thais who view Cambodia as the party that provoked the dispute and the external actor as exerting unwarranted pressure,” the analyst said. “At this juncture, showing weakness is not an option.”
A opinion study in August found that more than half of those surveyed believed Thailand should not be in partnership with Cambodia. It also found many were doubtful about the external mediation efforts in the conflict. Almost two-thirds of respondents said such involvement was in the interest of the superpowers, not Thailand. Fewer than 10% agreed such involvement was intended to bring about peace.
At temporary housing in Ubon Ratchathani, evacuees doubted the confident assertions of bringing peace. “He is entitled to his opinion,” said one older woman diplomatically.
But evacuees were divided over what the Thai authorities should do next. A senior military official told media this week that the military aimed to crush Cambodia’s military capability, rendering it harmless in the long term.
“Each person has their own opinion,” said Rinda Metmat, 44. “My wish is that no one suffers. I feel sorry for the soldiers, for their families and their children. Cambodian soldiers also have families. I think they also desire peace.”
Some question whether talks can succeed, regardless of efforts by external parties. “It’s not going to end no matter how many parties involved [in talks], two countries or with a third party, it’s not going to be resolved,” said Rangsan. “Talking never seems to lead to anywhere.”